Husband and I tried a new recipe today. It was muy delicious. Polenta Stuffed Poblano Peppers from Real Simple. I should have taken some photos of finished product, but once we started eating, it was just too hard to stop! Plus, it was pretty typical “Mexican-Style” food: messy but yummy.
I made some pretty minor modifications. The first was the addition of a jalapeno to the broiled vegetables. We like our food a little spicy and I thought that would be a good addition. Plus, we had an extra jalapeno in the fridge and because we are leaving in a couple of days, I didn’t want it to go to waste. The second addition was chorizo sausage to the salsa on top of the peppers. Husband is not a vegetarian and needs his protein. I was not convinced that it would be a good addition but it worked really well.
But my problem has nothing to do with the finished product; it is about polenta.
We really like polenta. I don’t buy “instant polenta”, I buy corn meal. Because isn’t that what polenta is? Corn meal? All of the instructions, er… recipes that I use for making polenta say to bring the liquid to a boil, then add the corn meal. Stir until it thickens, usually about 5-8 minutes.
But here’s my dilemma; my polenta never needs 5 minutes to cook until it’s thick. It’s usually only about 30 seconds. The polenta is good, it’s not gluey or anything like that. What am I doing wrong? Am I doing anything wrong? Should I just go with it and call it yummy? Everyone seems to like my polenta so I thought I’d share my “recipe”.
My “perfect” polenta recipe:
- 1 part corn meal
- 3.25 parts liquid (I use milk or cream. Usually not 100% cream, but about half cream, half milk. It’s whatever is left over in the fridge. I’ve never tried water, but I guess it would work. All of the recipes seem to recommend it. Why 3.25 parts liquid? Because it usually sits for about 20 minutes before it gets served. If you are the type of person that is “organized” and “prepared”, then you can probably decrease the amount of liquid to 3 or 3.1 parts.)
- Olive oil
- Cheese, about 1/2 part. I usually use parmesan; the Kraft shredded kind in the shaker bottle, because that’s what in the fridge. If I have some real parmesan (the aged kind), that is really nice. But the recipe above uses goat cheese. It’s more expensive but is nice!
Bring liquid to an almost boil. If water, you can ignore it. If milk/cream, you need to stir every once in awhile. Add the corn meal while whisking. I usually add in a pretty fast stream, but not all at once. If you don’t whisk or stir, you’ll get yucky lumps. After the corn meal is added, add about 1-2 tablespoons of olive oil and the cheese and stir until thick. “They” say 5-8 minutes, but it never takes me more than 30 seconds to reach that point. After it’s thick enough, Turn off the heat. I then pour a little olive oil on top (1 tablespoon maybe?) and put the lid on until it’s time to serve.
Viola. Perfect polenta.
What I always hate about the cooking sites are phrases like: “Stir until thick” or “Cook until done.” What’s thick? What’s done? I need more details!!! So here’s the nitty gritty about “thick”. Once the whisk (and yes, a whisk is really important) starts leaving soft peaks in the mixture, it’s probably thick enough. You’ll start to feel more and more resistance as you stir. Once your wrist starts to complain a little, stop. But what I think about is this, “would I want to eat it now?” You don’t want to stir until it’s the consistency that you eat it at because it sits, it will firm up.
What is this whole “part” thing? Where are the cups and oz and lbs?!? And how many parts does does a person eat anyway? The rule of thumb that I use is 1/4 cup of polenta for two people. That usually makes a tad too much and I end up throwing some away, but corn meal is cheap. So is olive oil when you buy it by the gallon like we do.
Anyway. I hope you make and enjoy some polenta sometime soon. It goes with anything. Our favorite? Steak and spinach with mushrooms. Or grilled lamb chops and asparagus. Or baked chicken with peas…





